Clio Professional CLIO Waterproof Pen Liner Kill Black XP

This really is long-lasting, even for oily lids like mine. It smudges, of course, but after hours of use and only because I'm really really oily lol. Couldn't erase the panda eyes w/o makeup remover though lol. The tip is also very fine, which is great for creating certain looks like a defined wing tip. There's no problem with application even when applied onto powder eyeshadow- but the colour was understandably more subdued.

I have very oily lids so this product is AMAZING. It is smudgeproof and waterproof, but since my lids are really oily this product can be wiped off if I rub my eyes too hard accidentally. Colour-wise this is black enough, not the blackest in the market but for its long-lasting effect I think it is a reasonable tradeoff (I have had it on for 19 hours before).

The Brush tip makes it very flexible and easy to work with, and fine enough to create sharp wings.